Tech Flesh 4: Mitochodrial Combustion at Club Parasite
An Interview With Hideaki Sena
Hideaki Sena is most likely the only untranslated contemporary
Japanese science fiction writer with a cult following in the United States. His
1995 novel, Parasite Eve, was made into a Playstation game soon after it
became a bestseller in Japan. Since then, over 1.5 million copies of the game
has been sold and the American film rights to the novel have been optioned by
the singer Madonna. Finally, there are plans underway to translate the novel
into English. Sena is a bit stunned by the success of his work both in Japan and
internationally: a pharmacology graduate student, he didn't imagine there would
be such a tremendous response to a story about human mitochondria that plan a
coup against the human race.
Parasite Eve takes as its starting point the 1987 announcement
by a team of American molecular biologists that they had discovered the
ancestral origins of homo sapiens. Working on the assumption that the DNA of
mitochondria (complex organelles that exist within cells and provide energy for
respiration and metabolism) have been passed down more or less intact through
the maternal lineage since the beginning of humankind, the team collected
mitchondrial DNA (mtDNA) from 136 women of diverse geographic and racial
origins. Running their data through a computer, the biologists then matched
their findings to a single ancestral mtDNA molecule (believed to be from an
African woman just under 200,000 years old).
Paleontological evidence and statistical reshuffling have since
undermined African Eve's legitimacy as a historical reality, but during the late
80s and early 90s she was a persistent icon, appearing on the cover of
Time and Newsweek and sparking both scientific and social debate.
At the time, most commentators seemed to find the idea of a common African
ancestor comforting, symbolic perhaps of the primacy of human connectedness over
racial divisiveness. Sena, however, saw the dark potential of this retelling of
the "human family." He conceived of a grim fantasy inspired by the pairing of
the African Eve hypothesis with the theory of the endosymbiotic origins of
mitochondria (the idea that mitochondria might have evolved from symbiotic
bacteria that once lived within the cells of other organisms). What if, he
speculated, the very mitochondria of "African Eve," passed down through
countless generations as organelles subsumed within human cellular structure,
suddenly decided to assert their biological right to autonomy? If that were to
occur, the common mtDNA that bound together the human race could be, to put it
mildly, a nasty liability: it would be as if a dormant, united army within our
collective selves suddenly awoke and declared it was independence day.
This, more or less, is the plot of Parasite Eve: a colony of
mitochondria, assembled in one unsuspecting human host, attempt a takeover of
the planet. The host (a young woman named Kiyomi ) happens to be the young wife
of a genetic scientist, Nagashima Toshiaki. When Kiyomi is rendered brain-dead
in a car accident, Toshiaki decides to keep her alive by cultivating tissue from
her liver. Soon, however, Toshiaki discovers that he has been manipulated: the
tissue, which Toshiaki calls "Eve-1," becomes a dense culture of sentient
mitochondria, which then incorporate into an entity resembling his dead wife.
Toshiaki is a classic Frankenstein figure updated for the 21st century; his
pride and selfishness cause him to bring to life a destructive force he cannot
control, and his sheer love of the technologies of genetic engineering blind him
to his very human limitations.
Though he claims allegiances to some horror and science fiction
authors, Sena's particular brand of hard-science biotech horror fiction is
fairly unique. If there are relatively few science fiction writers in the United
States who have begun to actively concern themselves with the anxieties of the
genetic age, there are even fewer in Japan. Surprisingly, given that anime is
one of the country's most prominent cultural exports, there is a relatively
small market for science fiction in Japan, and Japanese science fiction writers
(including Hideaki Sena, whom Asia Week has now dubbed the "Steven King
of Japan") generally pitch their novels as "horror" fiction instead of sci fi.
In the following interview, I corresponded with Sena about his past,
current and future projects, and asked him what he thought about the interface
between science, science fiction writers, and a biotech-obsessed,
CTheory: First, I would like to ask you about your decision to write
science fiction. Am I correct in understanding that you are a scientist who has
decided to become (at least for part of the time) a science fiction writer? What
motivated you to do this? You mention that you have written other novels that
featured biotechnology: could you say more about this?
Hideaki Sena: I have been writing so-called stories since I was an
elementary school student. At first, I wished to become a comic book artist, and
as time went by, a mystery writer. I started to write science fiction when I was
14 or 15 years old. My first published novel is Parasite Eve (1995). It
won a Japan Horror Novel Prize but you can say this novel is science fiction. My
second novel is Brain Valley (1997), which was the winner of the Nihon SF
Taisho Award (Japanese Nebula). My third novel The August Museum, which
was published in October 2000, is a sort of modern fantasy & science fiction
novel. Parasite Eve and Brain Valley featured biotechnology, and
my novella "Gene" (1996) is about the genome project. Frankly speaking, I do not
feel like a science fiction writer, since my first published novel Parasite
Eve received a horror fiction award. I am a member of Science Fiction &
Fantasy Writers of Japan, but I also attend Mystery Writers of Japan and The
Japan Writers' Association meetings. But basically I do like to think about
science, to take science into account so I always describe scientific concepts
in my books. I read many science fiction stories in my childhood, and
consequently my stories have a trace of science fiction.
CTheory: Do you find that your fiction communicates ideas that
scientists are themselves discussing, ideas about science that capture the
popular imagination, or some of both?
Hideaki Sena: Both, I think. Always my stories are a mixture of
scientific speculations and popular imagination. But the ratio of two ideas is
different in each story: Brain Valley is constructed mainly of practical
scientific speculations, but the most important idea of this book is fictional,
I mean, we can't write scientific papers using this idea. Parasite Eve is
constructed with a more popular imagination than Brain Valley. So many
readers in Japan consider Parasite Eve as horror fiction and Brain
Valley as science fiction.
CTheory: Do you feel that your work is read differently by scientists
and non-scientists? Have you gotten any particularly notable reactions to
Parasite Eve? You seemed to suggest in your email that you might have an
overly enthusiastic following.
Hideaki Sena: Most of my readers are non-scientists. Simply they are
amazed and enjoy the vivid descriptions of scientific experiments, an operation
of organ transplant, or the environment of biochemical labs, since there are
very few novels which describe this field in Japan. Many biochemists welcomed my
novel, because they felt my novel is introducing the true atmosphere of science
labs. But some scientists are repelled because they didn't like my 'fictional
ideas'. They thought scientist should not tell a 'lie', even in a novel. When my
second novel Brain Valley was published, I analyzed readers' impressions
using reader cards included in the books. In these questionnaire cards, there
are categories about readability and difficulty. About 56% of my readers felt
the book was difficult or very difficult. But also, 84% of readers felt this
book is enjoyable or very enjoyable. It is obvious that: my readers were
enjoying the difficulty of scientific terms and scientific descriptions. The
rather difficult scientific description does not spoil the interest of the
CTheory: What science fiction writers have you found particularly
influential? If you include Japanese science writers in this list, can you
describe their work for an audience that might be unfamiliar with them?
Hideaki Sena: I love books by Dean Koontz, Richard Matheson, William
Goldman and Richard Preston. I know they are not science fiction writers, but I
studied how to write novels from them. I am a big collector of Koontz' books. In
1998 an immensely critical book about Koontz was published. This is a
collaborative work with one of my friends, a translator (the title is
Complete Dean Koontz). I was influenced by his book How to write
Best-Selling Fiction (1981). When I was young, my favorite science fiction
stories were by Sakyo Komatsu (1931 -), Taku Mayumura (1934 -), and comics of
Osamu Tezuka (1928 - 1931) and Fujio Fujiko. Mr. Komatsu is the author of the
Titanic bestseller Japan Sinks (Nihon Chinbotsu) (1973). Mr. Mayumura
wrote many excellent juvenile science fiction stories, some of them were made
into movies, TV dramas or animation movies. Mr. Tezuka is the most famous comic
book artist in Japan. There are many masterpieces, including Astro Boy
(Tetsuwan Atom) The Firebird (Hinotori) Here goes a third-eye boy
(Mitsume ga Toru) The Crater The Jungle Emperor (Jungle
Taitei) Black Jack etc. Especially I love the comics of Mr. Fujikos.
Fujio Fujiko is the pen name of two comic artists, Mr. Fujio A. Fujiko (1934 -)
and Mr. Fujio F. Fujiko (1933 - 1996). They were influenced by American movies
and books. Particularly Mr. F read a lot of science fiction from the golden age
of comics, and he borrowed many ideas from them when he wrote comics. I learned
about the writings of science fiction through his comics.
CTheory: Are there any Japanese science fiction writers — even if they
haven't been particularly influential — who are also writing about
biotechnology? Would you say that their work is different in any way from the
work of the few American science fiction writers who are engaging with this
Hideaki Sena: Mr. Tatsuaki Ishiguro (1961 -), an M.D. at Tokyo
University, writes marvelous science fiction about biotechnology. He usually
writes his story as a medical paper or a scientific review: they include some
figures (such as DNA sequence data), tables, and photos. Mr. Sakyo Komatsu wrote
The Day of Resurrection (Hukkatsu no Hi) in 1964. This is a classic virus
disaster novel set in Japan and was made into a major motion picture as
Virus in 1980. Some novelists write books about biotechnology in Japan,
but I think most of them are not considered science fiction writers but mystery
or mainstream fiction writers. In Japan, science fiction does not have a wide
market, so publishers avoid labelling them as science fiction writers.
CTheory: Why do you think so little current Japanese science fiction
has been translated into English? It seems, at least, that far more is being
written than translated.
Hideaki Sena: I heard that Americans do not like to read foreign books
as entertainment: many American people want some exoticism in foreign books. I
think you might know a writer Ms. Banana Yoshimoto. She is one of the
best-selling authors in Japan. Her most famous novel, Kitchen was
translated into English several years ago. But I was amazed when I saw a photo
of a geisha on the cover jacket of the translated version, even though her story
is not exotic at all. American people enjoy Japanese comics and
animations. Many are translated into English. On the other hand, for Japanese
entertainment novel writers, it is very hard to find a good professional
translator. There are some people who can translate classic literature, or
non-genre mainstream fiction, like Yukio Mishima or Kensaburo Oe, but there are
very few people who can translate Japanese mystery, horror or science fiction.
CTheory: When you wrote Parasite Eve, did you think of yourself
as writing for a Japanese audience or an international audience? Can you think
of any concerns in your work that are specific to Japanese science fiction?
Hideaki Sena: When I wrote Parasite Eve, I didn't think of
myself as writing for a specific audience. But I think my novel is enjoyable to
an international audience since my story is entertaining. I tried to write some
sociological discussions about the Japanese medical system in Parasite
Eve. Even though it is not an international issue, I think readers can
understand this is one of the themes of the book.
CTheory: Can you tell us something about the reaction to your novel in
Japan? I know that it was very popular: were you surprised at its popularity?
Hideaki Sena: I was very surprised when my book was ranked at the top
of the bestseller list. I think people loved the novelty of this book: since
Parasite Eve was awarded the Japan Horror Novel Prize, many people were
amazed that 'science' was introduced to the field of 'horror' fiction. Also I
could say that there are many medical doctors who write novels but there are
very few people writing novels who study basic molecular biology in Japan.
Consequently many people are interested in my work.
CTheory: I'm curious about all of the different media versions of
Parasite Eve: book, game, TV movie, now possibly feature film. How did it
happen that your novel was transformed into a PlayStation game? Have you seen or
played the game? If you have, how would you say it relates to the book? Are
there any other current or pending versions of the story?
Hideaki Sena: There are several different media versions of
Parasite Eve: a movie (not a TV movie, but a Big Screen film), a comic
(manga), PlayStation game (part 1 and part 2), and a manga version of the
PlayStation game story (the title is "Parasite Eve DIVA"). The manga
version is the most faithful version to my novel. The story of the Play-Station
game (part 1) is the sequel to my novel. But none of characters is identical to
my story. The story was written by game designers, so I did not know the game
story until it was sold. The project of the PlayStation game was between Square
Company and my publisher. So far, there is no other pending version of the
CTheory: Parasite Eve takes as a starting point the idea of
3Mitochondria Eve2 or 3African Eve2. In discussions of this 3Eve2 in the
American media — and in statements made by some American scientists — what seems
to be emphasized is the idea that this 3Eve2 is an indication that all mankind
is genetically intertwined: this is supposed to be a good thing, a strike
against racial particularity. Your novel focuses instead on the dangers of this
genetic interconnection: Eve is able to communicate to the mitochondria in
humans, forcing spontaneous combustion. What was the genesis of your thinking
about 3Eve2? Was it related at all to discussions of 3Mitochondria Eve2 that
were taking place in Japan at the time, and if so, what were those discussions?
Hideaki Sena: When I wrote Parasite Eve, I engaged in research
work about the fatty acid metabolism in rat liver mitochondria so mitochondria
was of primary interest. At that time, a TV program about mitochondrial
symbiosis was on the air. Also, there was a best-selling popular science book
(non-fiction) about Mitochondrial Eve and the selfish gene, so a concept of
"Mitochondrial Eve" was somehow familiar in Japan. But many scientists
criticized that popular science best-seller because of many questionable
descriptions. When Parasite Eve was published, many scientists thought of
me in the same category, but gradually they recognized I had a different policy
about science writing. Today the author of that first book is regarded as a
pseudo-science writer. The monster in my book Parasite Eve is not
identical to the genetic meaning of "Mitochondrial Eve". SHE is a monster made
from hepatocytes of a modern human, Kiyomi, a wife of a main character. So there
is a little trick of description in my book. SHE is just borrowing an image of
CTheory: How much of the actual science of Parasite Eve is
Hideaki Sena: I am not sure the following is the proper reply to this
question or not. I have recently written a popular science book Life with
Mitochondria, which was published in December, 2000. In this book, I have
introduced some recent scientific topics about mitochondria with reference to
Parasite Eve. Mitochondiral RNA sets the development of the host. Also
mitochondria works as a switch of the host death.
CTheory: I have seen the Japanese television version of 3Parasite
Eve2 what are some of the differences between this film and your book?
Hideaki Sena: The first half of the movie is very similar to my story,
but the latter half deviates from the original story. I think it would have cost
a lot of money to produce a film completely faithful to my story.
CTheory: Do you think that the novel suggests that there is something
very seductive about the power of biotechnology itself? In other words, the
scientist seems driven to regenerate his wife's cells simply because he can do
so. So what do you feel personally about the ethics of biotechnology research?
What has influenced your beliefs on this subject?
Hideaki Sena: First of all, my novels are entertainment fiction. So
sometimes I overstate the facts, sometimes I pick up a special case to entertain
readers, or to tell readers the symbols. I'm not insisting on the danger of
biotechnology in Parasite Eve. But I would like to point out that
scientists sometime 'fall in love' with their cultured cells or their
experimental animals. They often say cancer cells are 'cute'. Some scientists
have said to me they could understand the feeling of culturing cells of their
wife. I tried to describe this feeling between scientists and the general
poublic in this book. I believe scientists should think about bio-ethics in the
same way. I think most scientists in Japan do not have a chance to think about
bio-ethics. Sometimes I participate in symposiums on bio-ethics as a writer, and
talk about these issues.
CTheory: Can you tell us something about your current writing project?
Is it also related to biotechnology? What current debates about biotechnology
does it touch on?
Hideaki Sena: I have just published my third novel, The August
Museum. This is a sort of a modern fantasy about virtual reality, Egyptian
archaeology and museology. My second novel Brain Valley was published in
1997. In this novel, I wrote about brain science, the sign language study of
chimps, artificial-life, and also a lot of scientific research results of alien
abduction, near-death experience, and out-of-the-body experience. I tried to
write about occult phenomena in a scientific way. I have just finished my newest
science nonfiction book, Life with Mitochondria, which was published in
December, 2000. Now I am writing a nonfiction science book about robotics. Also,
I have a plan to write some novellas about robotics, a novel about the influenza
virus, and a nonfiction book about museology.
Lisa Lynch is an Assistant Professor of English and Media Studies at Catholic
University. She writes on biotechnology and risk culture.
© CTheory. All Rights Reserved